Total Pageviews

Friday, March 27, 2015


Mufti government embarrassed over recommending 'retired ASP' as PSC member

◆Raj Bhawan returns panel with serious observations

 
Ahmed Ali Fayyaz
_______

JAMMU, March 25: In its first major goof up after taking over on March 1 in the Indian-administered Jammu & Kashmir, Mufti Mohammad Sayeed's PDP-BJP coaltion government has recommended a "retired additional Superintendent of Police" for the membership of the prestigious State Public Service Commission (PSC). It has been virtually turned down by Raj Bhawan which has raised serious questions over the way Mufti's government has laboured under favouritism in recommending members for the top Constitutional body.

Cabinet on March 15 had cleared six names to fill up some vacancies in the PSC which has become defunct after retirement of its Chairman and all the eight members in the last several years. Mufti's government had subsequently recommended six nominations to the Governor who is the competent authority to appoint Chairman and members for the autonomous body that makes selection of gazetted officers for the State government. While as the Chairman of PSC is by law equivalent to the rank and status of Chief Secretary, men and women of eminence in public service, not above 65 years of age, are normally appointed as members.

Currently Vice Chairman in J&K Lakes and Waterways Development Authority, Lateef-uz-Zamaan Deva, has been recomnended as Chairman. Sources said that Raj Bhawan, which had issued a special release of advice while rejecting the recommendations of Omar Abdullah government in December 2014, was not satisfied even with Mr Dev's nominations as being from 1984 batch of Kashmir Administrative Service (KAS), he is holding the rank of only a Secretary to government and is junior to dozens of senior IAS officers manning the higher positions of Commissioner-Secretary, Principal Secretary and Financial Commissioner.

Significantly, even a senior IAS officer of 1982 batch, Khursheed Ahmad Ganai, who is currently holding rank of FC (equivalent to Chief Secretary, has worked as additional Secretary in Union government and is due to retire later this year, failed to become PSC Chairman when Governor turned down Omar government's panel of nominees.

However, questions were not raised over Mr Deva's nomination by Mufti government as he has retained reputation of an upright officer and is known for honesty and integrity. Mr Deva has been inducted into IAS with effect from the year 2002.

Rishi Kumar Dogra, G.R. Bhagat, Prof. Mushtaq Wani, retired academic Indu Kilam and retired KAS officer Munshi Muzaffar Hussain have been recommended as members by the Mufti government.

Questioning the "due diligence" of the General Administration Department (GAD), which functions directly under the control of Chief Secretary and Chief Minister, Governor is said to have pointed out how even the junior officials with no significant contribution to public or civil service have also been recommended for appointment. Highly placed official sources revealed that the Governor's observation was based on a "heap of complaints" received by Raj Bhawan.

In some of the complaints, it has been highlighted that Rishi Kumar Dogra had joined the feeding stream of Kashmir Police Service as Dy SP in 1984 when he was in service as a teacher. He remained "absconding" for about 11 years when he was posted as Dy SP District Armed Reserve in Leh. His services were subsequently terminated by the government .

However, during Mufti's government in 2003, Mr Dogra surfaced with a submission and court order that he may be taken back into the government. With a break of 12 years in his service, he was allowed to join back and posted on a vacancy of Dy SP in Sher-e-Kashmir Police Academy Udhampur. Director of academy, Mr Masood Chowdhary, upon retirement and appointment as Vice Chancellor Baba Ghulam Shah Badshah University, got Mr Dogra on deputation as Officer on Special Duty in the University. He held office at the university's Jammu office at Sainik Colony. It has been pointed out by the complainants that Mr Dogra, who was neither "Professor" nor held a sensitive government position where his integrity could be at test, retired only as an additional SP.

It has been pointed out in one of the complaints that after his retirement as a junior rung State officer, G.R. Bhagat had publicly joined a political party. Photographs of the National Conference workers putting garlands on Mr Bhagat at Sher-e Kashmir Bhawan of Jammu, have been mailed to Raj Bhawan. However, Mr Bhagat is on record to have contradicted his joining any political party.

According to knowledgeable sources, to avoid further embarrassment, Government was likely to push only Mr Deva's nomination as Chairman. "A fresh panel is likely to be cleared by the Cabinet and submitted to Raj Bhawan", said a source who insisted that "extensive lobbying" was going on in favour of and against different individuals. Governor N.N. Vihra is understood to have made it clear that any nominations based merely on somebody's political or bureaucratic clout, would not be endorsed. "Parameters of merit, integrity, competence and public reputation, as laid down in different Supreme Court judgments and ordere in the last few years for such appointments, will be strictly adhered to", said a senior Raj Bhawan source.

END

Wednesday, March 25, 2015

NC MLC disturbs Mufti’s Govt on non-existent “Disturbed Areas Act”

Ahmed Ali Fayyaz
_______
Jammu, March 24: The opposition National Conference member Dr Bashir Ahmad Veeri generated a high voltage drama in the Upper House of Legislature in the Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir while floating a resolution---followed by an adjournment motion---on Tuesday for revocation of a law that has ceased to exist after October 1998.

The special law--- initially titled in Governor’s Rule in 1990 as “The Jammu and Kashmir Disturbed Areas Act, 1990 (Governor's Act No. 12 of 1990; in President’s Rule in 1992 as “The Jammu and Kashmir Disturbed Areas Act, 1992” and in Dr Farooq Abdullah’s civilian government in 1997 as “The Jammu and Kashmir Disturbed Areas Act, 1997---had given special powers to magistrates and officers of the armed branch of J&K Police for fighting militancy.
Being of temporary nature and subject to legislative review, the law expired on October 7, 1998, when Dr Abdullah’s government and following governments did not grant it’s enforcement any extension.

Veeri’s resolution, which was disallowed by Legislative Council Secretariat for being non-existent, read: “This august House resolves that in view of improving security environment in the State of Jammu and Kashmir, “Disturbed Areas Act” may be revoked with immediate effect in the larger interest of people of the State”.

Veeri pressed the matter in the House while bringing a motion, seeking adjournment of the Question Hour and a special debate on the laws that grant extraordinary powers and immunity against “any act done in good faith” by officers of Police and armed forces. Council officials said it was pending disposal with Chairman Amrit Malhotra whose is from Congress party and whose term would end on March 27.
With most of the people, including those in media, politics and bureaucracy, being little educated about the law, rejection of Veeri’s resolution generated a debate in different circles, particularly on television news channels. It was projected as if the PDP-BJP, headed by Chief Minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed, was averse to a debate on the issue of special powers enjoyed by the armed forces. It forced the government to issue an official clarification in the evening, making it clear that the DAA had ceased to exist after October 7, 1998, and as such there could be no debate on its “revocation”.

The clarification has obviously put the NC MLC in an embarrassing situation. Not perhaps properly educated and prepared for a discussion on the subject, the MLC possibly wanted revocation of the two notifications, issued by Governor in 1990 and 2001, declaring entire State of J&K, excluding the Ladakh districts of Leh and Kargil, as “Disturbed Areas”, under Section 3 of a different law that granted special powers to the officers of the central armed forces fighting armed rebellion in the State.
The law related to the special powers of the military and paramilitary forces, including Air Force personnel engaged in counterinsurgency operations, was initially titled as the Armed Forces (Jammu and Kashmir) Special Powers Act, 1990.  It came into force on July 5, 1990, and was notified by Governor Girish Chander Saxena’s government on July 6, when Mufti Mohammad Sayeed was the Union Home Minister.

Section 3 of AFSPA authorises the Governor, but more significantly also the Central government, to declare any areas of the State as “Disturbed Areas) so as to grant special powers to the armed forces. The Governor’s notification was published under signature of Additional Chief Secretary (Home) J&K Government vide SRO NO. SW 4, Dated 6-7, 1990, in the State Gazette. It declared all six districts of Kashmir province---Srinagar, Budgam, Baramulla, Kupwara, Anantnag and Pulwama---besides areas falling in the 20 Km strip on the LoC in Jammu’s Poonch and Rajouri districts as “Disturbed Areas” and granted special powers to the central armed forces.
AFSPA-1990 received President’s assent on September 10, 1990. It was published by Legislative Department of the Union Ministry of Law and Justice in an extraordinary gazette of the Government of India on September 11, 1990.

The President issued a Proclamation on the 8th July 1990 under Article 356 of the Constitution of India, in relation to the State of Jammu and Kashmir declaring inter alias that the powers of the Legislature of the State shall be exercisable by or under the authority of Parliament. Parliament, under Article 357(1)(a) of the Constitution, conferred on the President, the powers of the Legislature of the State of Jammu and Kashmir to make the laws vide the Jammu and Kashmir State Legislature (Delegation of Powers) Act, 1992 (21 of 1992), as Governor had dissolved the State Assembly, following Chief Minister Farooq Abdullah’s resignation, in 1990. In 1992, Parliament ratified the Governor’s law as AFSPA-1992 in to-to.
When Dr Abdullah came back to power in 1996, his government left the AFSPA intact and the Governor’s “Disturbed Areas” notification, dated July 6, 1990, in force. It was never amended or repealed by the successive governments either.

On August 10, 2001, Governor, on the recommendation of Dr Abdullah’s Cabinet, declared all six districts of Jammu division---Jammu, Kathua, Poonch, Rajouri, Udhampur and Doda----as “Disturbed Areas” vide SRO 351. It was issued by Principal Secretary Home vide No: Home-219/97-ISA Dated 10.8.2001.
It is by virtue of these two notification, both issued under Section 3 of AFSPA, that Central armed force are enjoying extraordinary powers in Kashmir and Jammu provinces.

 Extraordinary powers under AFSPA
Under AFSPA, any commissioned or non-commissioned officer or warrant officer, is authorised

“(a) if he is of opinion that it is necessary so to do for the maintenance of public order, after giving such due warning as he may consider necessary, fire upon or otherwise use force, even to the causing of death, against any person who is acting in contravention of any law or order for the time being in force in the disturbed area prohibiting the assembly of five or more persons or the carrying of weapons or of  things capable of being used as weapons or of firearms, ammunition or explosive substances;

(b) if he is of opinion that it is necessary so to do, destroy any arms dump, prepared or fortified position or shelter from which  armed attacks are made or are likely to be made or are attempted to be made, or any structure used as training camp for armed volunteers or utilized as a hide-out by armed gangs or absconders wanted for any offence; 

(c) arrest, without warrant, any persons who has committed a cognizable offence or against whom a reasonable suspicion exists that he has committed or is about to commit a cognizable offence and may use such force as may be necessary to effect the arrest; 

(d) enter and search, without warrant, any premises to make any such arrest as aforesaid or to recover any person believed to be wrongful restrained or confined or any property reasonably suspected to be stolen property or any arms, ammunition or explosive substances believed to be unlawful kept in such premises, and may for that purpose use such force as may be necessary, and seize any such property, arms, ammunition or explosive substances”.

Besides, no criminal proceedings can operate under any such officer as all of the officers’ acts during counterinsurgency conditions are deemed to have been done “in good faith”.

END

J&K POLITICIANS’ AFSPA HYPOCRACY!

 

National Conference MLC Dr Bashir Ahmad Veeri today brought a resolution in Legislative Council seeking revocation of "Disturbed Area Act" in J&K. It was disallowed with the reply that the DAA has expired in 1998 and it does no more exist. It is a fact that Jammu and Kashmir Disturbed Areas Act 1992 [Act No: 4 0f 1992], which was originally titled and enforced as Jammu and Kashmir Disturbed Areas Act 1990 [Governor's Act No: 12 of 1990], and which gave special powers to Police and other forces not covered under J&K AFSPA 1990, has lapsed on 7-10-1998. Successive governments of Dr Farooq Abdullah, Mufti Sayeed, Ghulam Nabi Azad, Governor Vohra and Omar Abdullah have not extended this law after 1998.

However, it appears, the MLC actually wanted the notifications, under which J&K areas have been declared as "Disturbed" and brought under purview of J&K AFSPA 1990, to be repealed. For that purpose, the MLC should have specifically called for revocation of Governor's Notification No: SW: 4 Dated 6th July 1990 (which declared all 6 districts of Kashmir valley as also 20 Km strip along LoC in Poonch and Rajouri as "Disturbed Areas" under Section:3 of Jammu and Kashmir Armed Forces Special Powers Act 1990) and also revocation of Governor's Notification SRO: 351 Dated 10th August 2001 (which declared all six districts of Jammu division as "Disturbed Areas" under Section 3 of J&K AFSPA 1990). If such a resolution is brought and passed by Assembly, it will force the State Government to send the Notification of Revocation to Governor [under section 3 of J&K AFSPA 1990] who is then bound to revoke the said notifications. Once that is done, no armed forces in J&K can have any special powers.

Let it also be clear that AFSPA 1958, which is in force in some North Eastern States of India, has never been and will never be applicable/ in force in J&K State. That is a completely irrelevant law with regard to J&K.

However, the most significant point of AFSPA 1990, passed by Parliament and enforced by Union Home Ministry when Mufti Mohammad Sayeed was Union Home Minister, is that the Governor has wrongfully given the State's sovereign power in the hands of the Central Government. J&K AFSPA 1990 gives the power of declaring an area as "Disturbed" to Governor (who any way has to function under the advice of State Cabinet) as well as to GOVERNMENT OF INDIA. This encroachment of the State's sovereign jurisdiction, which has been shifted to New Delhi under the direction of then Home Minister Mufti Sayeed, needs to be amended. It needs simple majority in J&K Legislature. Since Mufti Sahab is now CM, he should himself initiate it alongwith revocation of the two Governor's notifications (under section 3 of J&K AFSPA) in which Central government has no power to resist____Ahmed Ali Fayyaz

Monday, March 23, 2015

Amid anti-Pak slogans, J&K Legislature condemns fidayeen attacks

Ahmed Ali Fayyaz
_____________

Jammu, March 22: Notwithstanding a walkout by the opposition National Conference (NC), which insisted on a special debate, both Houses of the State Legislature in Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir on Sunday condemned the previous week’s twin fidayeen attacks in Jammu.

Legislative Assembly, followed by Legislative Council, passed separate resolutions urging New Delhi to impress upon the Government of Pakistan to take “all measures for preventing such dastardly acts in future for a lasting peace in the region so that the initiatives towards peace do not get derailed and allow the people of Jammu & Kashmir to get the dividends of peace process”.

“The House, which is the most legitimate democratic institution representing the aspirations of the people of the State, resolves that the movement for peace and reconciliation will be carried forward with full force and the enemies of people will be defeated”, said the resolution.

Proceedings in the Assembly were marred in the very beginning as members of Congress, NC as well as the ruling BJP, created ruckus over the twin strikes in which nine people, including four militants, died in Kathua and Samba districts on Friday and Saturday. Congress and BJP members, all from Jammu, shouted anti-Pakistan slogans even as the former contended that the PDP-BJP government’s policies had raised the morale of the separatists and the militants had executed such type of attacks after a long time.

Chief Minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed intervened with his strong condemnation of the fidayeen strikes and announced that the Legislature would pass a resolution and impress upon the Centre to convey to Islamabad, “which itself is embroiled with terrorism”, to ensure that such attacks did not subvert the peace process. “Pakistan’s establishment shall have to control it. Otherwise how can the vehicle of peace surge forward?” he said.

Mufti referred to General Musharaf’s period and recalled that “not a single incident of terror happened from Kargil to Kathua in those six years”. He said that the J&K Assembly had the “biggest representative character” as its elected members had come with a massive mandate. It said Assembly would take a call and convey to Pakistan through New Delhi that such incidents would have to stop. “The relations between India and Pakistan won’t improve if such incidents continue to happen,” he said, while calling for a greater vigil on the borders to prevent such attacks.

While asserting that such dastardly acts are timed to subvert the peace process that has lately resumed between India and Pakistan, Mufti said such forces were desperate to disturb peace in the region. They won’t be allowed to succeed, he said. “If we have to carry forward the process of reconciliation, such incidents should not be repeated”.

“We have invested a lot in the peace process. There are some rogue elements which in the name of religion are carrying out such acts. These elements will not be allowed to damage the fabric of peace in the State,” Chief Minister said.

NC walkout

NC MLAs disagreed with CM’s suggestion of merely passing a resolution. They demanded adjournment of the business and a special debate on the status of internal security besides circumstances leading to the fidayeen attacks. Speaker Kavinder Gupta did not admit the motion. Thereupon, all the NC MLAs led by Omar Abdullah staged a walkout in protest.

END

Saturday, March 21, 2015


Mufti to Omar: We never knew you had detained just 16 under PSA

·        ‘Jammu and Ladakh should take ownership of J&K’s special status

·        ‘J&K coalition adds diversity to BJP’s mandate’

·        ‘No government jobs to Pakistan refugees’

 
Ahmed Ali Fayyaz

_______
Jammu, March 20: Chief Minister and head of the PDP-BJP coalition in the Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir State, Mufti Mohammad Sayeed, on Friday refused to lend much of importance to the fidayeen attack in Kathua----first after the Assembly elections, in which six people got killed----while asserting that involving Pakistan and “internal stake holders” was necessary for resolution of the Kashmir imbroglio.

Replying to the two-day-long debate on Governor’s address in Legislative Assembly, Mufti claimed that the security scenario had considerably improved in the last several years. He said unfortunately some people were projecting as if Kashmir was a “big prison”.
“Omar Sahab during your regime, we never knew that the total number of the people detained under Public Safety Act was just 16. We were told they are in thousands. But it is the fault of your men who didn’t tell us the real number. When we took charge and inquired about it, who jo kehte hain na ki bahut shour sunte the seene mein dil ka, jo cheera tou ik qatra-e-khoon nikla. We found that their total number was only 37 and 20 of them were foreigners. Of the 16 J&K State subjects, only 3 stone pelters are in jail under PSA”, Mufti told his predecessor Omar Abdullah.

Mufti said he wanted to release the political prisoners to deflate the propaganda that India was on the course of repression and that the entire Kashmir was like a big prison.
“When I took over as Chief Minister in 2002, I released Syed Ali Shah Geelani from a jail in Jharkhand. Congress as well as BJP, Vajyapee as well as Manmohan Singh, supported us to bring about a thaw. Yet again, this deal with BJP is never for grabbing the post of Chief Minister. We just wanted to seize the opportunity of retrieving J&K from the whirlpool of turmoil. PDP had a natural role for its mandate in Kashmir and BJP in Jammu. This alliance in the country’s only Muslim-majority State also adds diversity to BJP’s mandate”, Mufti added.

Mufti asserted that the recent Assembly elections, “fairest ever in last 60 years”, which witnessed a huge voter turnout, had restored the faith of the people of Jammu and Kashmir in democracy. Assembly, he said, had become a major power centre and an institution of credible representative character.
“In 1985, I contested and won the election from Jammu’s RS Pora. Today, the situation is totally different. PDP got only 28 seats in the Assembly elections but in the previous Lok Sabha elections it had maintained lead in 41 Assembly segments”.

Mufti gave credit to Vajpayee for initiating trade and diplomatic liaison with Pakistan and sounded optimistic of a smooth sailing yet again in 2015. He argued that maintenance of peace was a must for development and good governance and therefore the two countries needed to hold dialogue and also engage the “internal stakeholders” in the peace process.

He described J&K as a shining example of the country’s secular credentials which “defies the logic of the two-nation theory and has acceded to the Indian Union”.
Mufti said the example of the BJP and PDP coming together, despite ideological and political differences, can be a model for inclusive governance. He said as the former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee had turned his Srinagar visit into a historic opportunity to reach out to Pakistan and script the agenda for peace. “Our partnership with Prime Minister Narendra Modi could make the power structure at the national level more inclusive and diverse” he added.

Referring to incidents at Chhatergam and Macchil, Mufti asserted that his Government was committed to take measures and examine the need to review the special laws being applied to the State. “There has been a lot of debate over removal of AFSPA. There is a need to re-look at it. My Government advocates a phase-wise removal of AFSPA from the areas which have been free of militancy for quite some time”.  

Highlighting the purpose of the Alliance between PDP and BJP, the Chief Minister stated that the new Government shall be empowered to take confidence building measures within and across the Line of Control (LoC) in J&K, thereby ensuring lasting peace. “We want to create an enabling environment for all round economic development of the State,” he said.

Chief Minister said that the Union Government had released Rs. 1,000 crore under “Prime Minister’s Package for Floods” for restoration of damage to public assets over and above around Rs. 1,100 crore already available with the State government under NDRF for emergency relief and temporary restoration. An amount of Rs. 820 crore, he said, had been spent under SDRF. “The work on commencement of permanent restoration has already begun. We are separately pursuing the release of a special package that would cater to the requirements of the affected people”.

Mufti described the Pakistani refugees settled in Jammu as a “human problem” but made it clear that the State government could not give them government jobs. He clarified that the livelihood boost as mentioned in the “Agenda for Alliance” means that his government would help the refugees in getting jobs in private sector.He said that a committee to be headed by Deputy Chief Minister Nirmal Singh would address the whole gamut of the refugees problem even as the refugees from PoK would get “one-time settlement package”.

Mufti said that in absence of the Kashmiri Pandits, the valley’s social fabric was incomplete and his government would encourage the migrants’ return and settle them in community villages like Hall in Pulwma-Shopian belt where all of the deserted houses were standing intact. His government would create “an enabling peaceful environment”.

 END

Friday, March 20, 2015

Omar says Mufti is dancing to the tunes from Nagpur

◆‘Agenda for Alliance is PDP’s total sell-out for power’

◆‘Let Cabinet revoke AFSPA, send file to Governor. Why bring Delhi in everything?’

◆‘Not a single Kashmiri has returned from Pak during Modi regime’


Ahmed Ali Fayyaz
_______
Jammu, March 19: Former Chief Minister and the opposition National Conference leader in the Legislative Assembly in the Indian-administered State of Jammu and Kashmir, Omar Abdullah, on Thursday alleged that the ruling People’s Democratic Party, which has formed the government in an alliance with Bharatya Janata Party, and its Chief Minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed were taking diktats from Nagpur---headquarters of the Hindu fundamentalist outfit Rashtriya Swayam Sevak Sangh [RSS], and undermining the State’ special constitutional status in exchange for power.

Speaking for about 50 minutes on Governor’s address and the ruling coalition’s Minimum Common Programme, titled “Agenda of Alliance”, in the Assembly, Abdullah maintained that Mufti and his PDP had compromised the Stat’s dignity and special status, besides the peoples’ interest, “only for gaining the power”. He asserted that Mufti had done total reversal of what he and other leaders of his party had been telling and promising the Kashmiris since 1999.

Abdullah pointed out that the coalition’s “Agenda of Alliance” carried nothing of the PDP’s plank of ‘Self Rule’ which Mufti’s party had been projecting as the resolution of the Jammu and Kashmir crisis. “Where’s your Self Rule, joint control mechanism, double currency, release of political detainees et al ?”, Abdullah asked the Treasury Benches.

“We were worried that you would wipe us out and deny us even 5 seats in the next elections by holding the talks with the BJP for some time and finally withdrawing with the assertion that the BJP had no regard for the State’s special position and political aspiration. But we in the NC and Congress were relieved when you compromised everything for the Chief Minister’s chair for six years and the lion’s share of Ministries and portfolios”, Abdullah said in pin-drop silence in the Assembly all through his speech.

Taking exception to the Mufti government issuing an order for maintaining dignity of the State Flag on March 12 but revoking the same on March 13, Abdullah asked: “Why did you withdraw the order? What was the compulsion? Was there a call from Nagpur, from Jhandewallan [RSS’ Delhi headquarters] or from Delhi?” He blasted the official spokesman’s averment that the March 12 order had been issued by the officials without the competent authority’s [Chief Minister’s] approval. “I have been a Chief Minister. I know that none of the officials would ever dare to issue such an order without the CM’s approval”, he asserted.

Abdullah challenged Mufti to produce the concerned file in the Assembly. “It will become clear in one minute whether it had the competent authority’s approval or not. Otherwise also, we are going to bring out the truth through an application under RTI”, he added.

Abdullah read out from newspaper reports what Mufti, his daughter Mehbooba and other PDP leaders had said about BJP during the recent Assembly elections. He elaborated how all the PDP leaders, particularly Mufti and Mehbooba, had labelled Modi and his BJP as the rank communalists and ruled out any alliance with them for gaining power in J&K.

“How did BJP become secular and a Kashmir-friendly party overnight? How did you forget your agenda and the peoples’ interest overnight? Have the BJP and the RSS become less communal now? How did you abruptly forget your tantrums on the Gujarat bloodshed [of 2002] and the martyrdom of Babri Masjid? Hasn’t a senior BJP leader just the other day said that the mosques were no religious places and these could be demolished anytime? Aren’t they using the words of Ramzade and Haramzade? Is this the deal of dignity you have given the Kashmiris?”, Abdullah asked Mufti and his Ministers.

“I admit we lost the elections for we failed to realise the peoples’ aspirations. Still we didn’t face the total rout you had predicted for us. We got more than that. But why did you get stuck on 28? Where are the 41 seats you were boasting of during the elections? We were at the receiving end and you had all the advantages---2010 turmoil, Afzal Guru’s execution, 2014 flood”, Abdullah added. “Now that your government is there from Delhi to here, where’s the mention of the Rs 44,000 crore flood relief in the Union Budget?”

Abdullah argued that rather than getting any concession over withdrawal of AFSPA from the Centre, Mufti had given the Union government right of interference in the State’s sovereign jurisdiction. “I admit, my Congress colleagues didn’t lend me support and I failed to revoke AFSPA. Now that you have formed the government with BJP, you must be enjoying their support. If withdrawal of AFSPA is purely a State matter, why don’t you do it in your Cabinet and send its file to Governor. We will accept that you have done what nobody else could ever”, Abdullah addressed Mufti.

The former Chief Minister reminded Mufti Prime Minister’s recent statement in the Parliament wherein Modi made it categorically clear that his government was strictly committed to implementation of the two Parliamentary resolutions on J&K. Abdullah elaborated that the two resolutions contained India’s unequivocal affirmation to retrieving the entire J&K terrories from Pakistan’s illegal occupation. “Is that the concession you have got from BJP? Would Pakistan ever enter into a dialogue where it would be asked by India to return the occupied territories?”, Abdullah said while ridiculing PDP’s talk of addressing the State’s external dimension.

“Had you prevailed on BJP and got these resolutions amended in the Parliament, we would have recognised it as your biggest achievement. Such talks have yielded nothing for 60 years and would not yield anything in the hundreds of years to come”, Abdullah asserted. He said that over 350 families of the Kashmiri youths, who had gone to Pakistan to become militants but abandoned militancy, had returned to home during his regime under the policy his government introduced for return and rehabilitation of the reformed militants.

“But not a single family has returned since the day this NDA government assumed office”, Abdullah said, claiming that Modi’s government had virtually frozen the rehabilitation scheme. He also lashed out on PDP for saying for 6 years that over 10,000 youth had been detained under Public Safety Act by the Omar government . “Now the other day when Mehboobaji was asked at India Today Conclave about the political prisoners, she put their total number at 16. I ask you where did those thousands of detenus go. You haven’t released a single of them”.

Over a dozen members spoke in favour of or against the Governor’s address in Thursday’s debate which would conclude with Chief Minister Mufti’s detailed reply on Friday evening.

END

NC MLA Aga Ruhullah calls Modi ‘killer of Muslims’

‘Nobody expected PDP to impose these killers as rulers in the Muslim majority State of J&K’

 Ahmed Ali Fayyaz
_______
Jammu, March 19: Former Minister and National Conference’s three-time MLA from Budgam Aga Syed Ruhullah on Thursday called Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his BJP as the “killers of the Gujarati Muslims” and launched scathing attacks on Mufti Mohammad Sayeed’s Peoples Democratic Party for “collaborating with BJP” in securing power in Jammu and Kashmir.

“At least in this Muslim-majority State [of Jammu and Kashmir] nobody expected PDP to collaborate with BJP in assuming power. Nobody expected them to tie their knot to the Muslim-killer, Gujarat-killer Modi and his BJP, the people who brought the unborn babies out of the wombs of their mothers to kill them. Everybody thought that these people may grab power in any other Indian State but not in this Muslim-majority State where they deserved to be condemned. These are the people who use the obnoxious words like "Ramzade aur doosre zade". These are the people who say brazenly that mosques are not the places of worship and that these could be demolished anytime”, Ruhullah grumbled on the floor of the House while speaking over Governor’s address.

“Nobody imagined that PDP would be hand-in-glove with these people in grabbing for them power in this State. Everybody aspired that the killers would be dismissed as killers at least in this State where Muslims, unlike other States, are under no fear for being in majority. What was their weakness here? What made them endorse the politics of the killers and bring them as rulers here?”, Ruhullah went on amid pandemonium from the vociferous BJP MLAs.

BJP’s associate member and Minister of State Pawan Gupta, MLA Ravinder Raina and others staged a strong protest against Ruhullah’s remarks, stressing on Speaker Kavinder Gupta to fully expunge the NC MLA’s “un-Parliamentary speech”. “Modi is the Prime Minister of this country. He has been elected as Head of Government by a massive majority of the country’s electorate. We will not allow anybody to "denigrate the country’s Prime Minister in this House and the State”, Raina said. He demanded Ruhullah withdraw his statement and tender an apology in the House.

Even as the BJP MLAs claimed that the Speaker had assured them expunction of the NC MLA’s “objectionable remarks” about Prime Minister and BJP, no such statement was released from his office till late on Thursday. Secretary Assembly Mohammad Ramzan did not respond to repeated calls from mediapersons.

‘NO QUESTION OF COMPROMISE on 370, AFSPA’

Speaking to mediapersons later outside the House, Raina asserted that BJP would in no circumstances do any compromise on its stand on Article 370 or the Jammu and Kashmir Armed Forces Special Powers Act. “Let it be clear to one and all that BJP will never enter into dialogue with any separatists until they accept the sovereignty and integrity of this country. We can talk to anybody but strictly within the ambit of the Constitution”, Raina said.

The BJP legislator from Nowshehra castigated the NC and the Congress leaders for dragging RSS into every controversy in J&K. “It’s highly deplorable that these people are dragging the Sangh into political mess. Sangh (RSS) is a purely social organisation which is independently doing its job of social reform”, he said.

END